FutureStructure

Tucson Electric Power's New Storage Systems Smooth Renewable Energy’s Intermittent Generation

These short-duration battery systems intend to bridge the time it takes to bring supplemental generating sources online after an outage, and to help with grid reliability by shoring up voltage and regulating power frequency when needed.

by David Wichner, The Arizona Daily Star, Tucson / May 8, 2017
Shutterstock

(TNS) -- Tucson Electric Power Co. recently completed two big energy-storage projects aimed at taking advantage of new technologies and smoothing out the intermittent generation of renewable-energy sources like solar and wind.

Chicago-based E.ON Climate & Renewables finished building a 10-megawatt capacity lithium-ion battery-storage facility and an accompanying 2-megawatt solar array at the University of Arizona Tech Park southeast of Tucson, known as the Iron Horse project.

In December, a subsidiary of Florida-based NextEra Energy Resources completed construction of a 10-megawatt lithium-ion energy storage system at a TEP substation near Interstate 10 and West Grant Road.

TEP will buy the solar power from E.On and pay capacity charges for both battery systems under power-purchase agreements.

The TEP installations are short-duration battery systems intended to bridge the time it takes to bring supplemental generating sources online after an outage, and to help with grid reliability by shoring up voltage and regulating power frequency when needed.

Long-duration storage systems are designed to keep customers’ lights on for hours during an outage — or even replace natural-gas plants fired up to handle demand peaks.

But those are more costly and have been mainly pursued in places with high electric rates like California and Hawaii.

TEP spokesman Joe Barrios said the short-run battery systems will help reduce costs by supplanting other grid-reliability measures.

“This is a pretty new technology that has become reliable, and the cost is now reasonable,” Barrios said.

TEP expects to spend about $1.7 million annually on the two new storage systems combined, under contract with E.On and NextEra.

Under a plan approved by the Arizona Corporation Commission, TEP will pay for the services through an existing purchased fuel and power surcharge that will cost the average customer about 13 cents per month, Barrios said.

Mark Frigo, an E.On vice president who heads the North American energy-storage business for the German-based company, said the short-term battery system at the Tech Park — the company’s first in North America — can pump out a full 10 megawatts of power for 15 minutes.

That can help even out grid power in places like Tucson, where solar arrays put out massive amounts of power, then drop off in the evening when demand soars, in what is know as a “duck curve.”

“That ramp-up and ramp-down puts a big stress on the transmission and distribution systems, and the batteries help you smooth that out and provide more grid resiliency,” Frigo said.

The storage systems are expected to save TEP money it would have to spend on other grid-stability measures, including standby gas combustion turbines that can take 10 minutes or more to start up.

“You can ramp it (storage) up very, very quickly,” Barrios said.

For example, he said, in early March TEP’s system experienced a voltage drop that prompted the utility to bring more generating resources online, but the system at the DeMoss Petrie substation instantly brought that circuit up to normal.

TEP plans to invest in 50 megawatts of additional energy storage in 2019, add another 50MW by 2021 and another 100MW in 2031, according to TEP’s most recent resource plan.

TEP isn’t alone in its storage expansion, in Arizona or nationally.

Arizona Public Service Co., the largest state-regulated utility, has agreed to buy a 4MW storage system for use with its company-owned rooftop solar program. APS installed a 1.5MW battery storage as a pilot project in Flagstaff in 2012.

In April, the self-governed Salt River Project announced a 20-year power purchase agreement with NextEra for a 10MW lithium-ion battery-storage system linked to a 20MW solar farm.

GTM Research, a Boston-based firm that studies the renewable-energy markets, projects the U.S. energy-storage market will grow from 221 MW in 2016 to roughly 2.6 gigawatts — one gigawatt equals 1,000 megawatts — in 2022.

The move to utility-scale energy storage has been pioneered in places like Hawaii, which because of its reliance on imported fuel has historically paid the highest prices in the nation.

The Aloha State has jumped all-in on local, renewable generating resources such as solar and wind, but the intermittency of those resources has resulted in a more brittle power grid.

“Island communities such as Hawaii have been at the forefront of implementing these types of (storage) solutions, and now on the mainland it’s been recognized, and the prices have come down so much that it’s becoming mainstream here,” E.On’s Frigo said.

Some utilities are moving toward using larger, longer-duration storage systems to replace so-called “peaker” generating plants — generally natural-gas combustion turbines — used to generate extra power during peak demand .

Hawaiian Electric has proposed a 20MW, five-hour-duration battery storage system paired with 28MW of solar in Kaua’i, to match peak demand with generation.

In California, which has mandated that state-regulated utilities install 1.3 gigawatts of storage by 2020, Southern California Edison has proposed a 100MW, four-hour battery system specifically designed to replace a gas peaker plant in Long Beach.

Barrios said TEP could install long-duration battery storage in the future, but for now plans to focus on short-run storage for grid resiliency.

Frigo said rapidly dropping prices for battery storage may convince TEP and other s to consider storage to replace the gas generators to handle peak demand, sooner rather than later.

“There are many in the power industry that believe batteries will become, in terms of cost, at parity with comparable peaking combustion turbines within the next two or three years,” he said.

©2017 The Arizona Daily Star (Tucson, Ariz.) Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.