Dec 4, 2009, By Todd Sander, Director Digital Communities
What's with all the angry people on TV these days? Some of the images from news reports from congressional town hall meetings held during the summer recess to discuss health-care reform made me cringe. The red-faced, shouting, spit-flinging tirades of so many people made me wonder if our nation can still have civilized public discourse. When you add to that a congressman shouting, "You lie!" at the president of the United States while he spoke to a joint session of Congress, you can't help but worry that perhaps the American democratic process has seen better days.
Of course, this sort of display during a public meeting is hardly new to local government officials. The "public comment" section of their weekly meeting agendas regularly evoke the angry and the rude seeking an audience for their tirades.
Those of us who believe in and support the governance process must find a way to help stop the current fad of people shouting past one another armed with little more than slogans and sound bites. Thoughtful criticism of government is an important part of the democratic process, but I blame the gasbag talking heads on cable channels and talk radio for fueling the flames of discord with little regard for the truth. Somewhere along the line, rumors and disinformation replaced data, facts and well reasoned thoughts as a foundation for political engagement.
So what can a local government IT person do about a problem that on the surface seems to call for an old-school fourth-grade teacher with a whistle, a ruler and an ability to enforce good manners and polite behavior?
First of all, we can resist getting angry even when everyone seems to be angry with us. As government continues to bring change to community life - and change will continue to come either as a result of new political policies or continuing financial strains brought about by the current recession - we can look for ways to mitigate angst and anger with data and facts. In my experience, people get angry when what they think they know just isn't so. Government has an obligation to be open, transparent and factual; and good IT can provide the cornerstone of efforts to meet that obligation.
That's because IT is politically neutral. It's neither Democrat nor Republican, liberal nor conservative. It's simply a tool for managing and delivering public service and a means for collecting and managing information upon which good decisions can be made. By working to get that information out of legacy systems and government files and making it available and easily accessible through Web 2.0 and social networking platforms, people who are interested can educate themselves with the truth and insert a dose of reality into public debate. The absence of facts leaves us with appearances, and on the basis of appearances people form perceptions that quickly become political fact. It's an unfortunate cycle IT professionals can help break.
The political holy warriors aren't going away anytime soon, but government can and should do more to provide support to those who are interested in truth and reason. It's the only way I can see us avoiding sitting in the dark nursing the burns that come from too much heat and too little light.
If you're interested in learning more about how some leading communities are using IT to improve the quality of their public debate, you can contact me at tsander@centerdigitalgov.com
MJ
Read real world deployments of technology in government from our sponsors.
View All Industry SolutionsBrowse hundreds of public sector career opportunities in GovTech's new jobs section. Popular job searches: government IT, public safety, GIS, transportation, CIO, security, health
Comments
Thoughtful criticism can be realised in public deliberation, in formats such as Citizens' Jury, convened to bring a facilitated, random sample of citizens into the policy-setting process. ICT can help by providing online collaboration platforms that easily connect participants who are distant, to deliberate in depth over time, with interactive problem-solving tools at their disposal. Such developments are happening now.
Another thing: ICT is not value-neutral. For example, Tim O'Reilly's vision for Gov2.0 is decidedly libertarian in nature, with the intent of making government small. Social networking generally rewards individual rather than communitarian activity. And those without net access are denied influence. So ICT design and deployment embeds social, political and cultural values. Online collaboration platforms must be rolled out carefully to avoid thoughtful criticism;-)Not as succinct as 'You lie', but just as inflammatory: "Lyrics of "For Jefferson and Liberty". The gloomy night before us lies, The reign of terror now is o'er; Its gags, inquisitors and spies, Its hordes of harpies are no more Rejoice, Columbia's sons, rejoice To tyrants never bend the knee But join with heart, and soul and voice For Jefferson and Liberty.
O'er vast Columbia's varied clime Her cities, forests, shores and dales; In riding majesty, sublime, Immortal liberty prevails, Rejoice etc. Hail! long expected glorious day Illustrious memorable morn: That freedom's fabric from decay Secures - for millions yet unborn. Rejoice etc. His country's glory, hope and stay, In virtues and in talents tried; Now rises to assume the sway, O'er freedom's temple to preside. Rejoice etc. Within its hallow'd walls immense No hireling band shall e'er arise; Array'd in tyranny's defence, To hear an injur'd people's cries. Rejoice etc. No lordling here with gorging jaws. Shall wring from industry its food; No fiery bigot's holy laws, Lay waste our fields and streets in blood. Rejoice etc. Here strangers from a thousand shores Compell'd by tyranny to roam; Shall find, amidst abundant stores, A nobler and a happier home. Rejoice etc. Here art shall lift her laurel'd head Wealth industry and peace divine; And where dark forests lately spread Rich fields and lofty cities shine. Rejoice etc. From Europe's wants and woes remote A dreary waste of waves between; Here plenty cheers the humble cot, And smiles on every village green. Rejoice etc. Here, free as air's expanded space, To every soul and sect shall be; That sacred privilege of our race, The worship of the Deity. Rejoice etc. These gifts, great Liberty, are thine, Ten thousand more we owe to thee; Immortal may their mem'ries shine, Who fought and died for Liberty. Rejoice etc. What heart but hails a scene so bright What soul but inspiration draws; Who would not guard so dear a right Or die in such a glorious cause. Rejoice etc. Let foes to freedom dread the name, But should they touch the sacred tree Twice fifty thousand swords would flame, For Jefferson and Liberty. Rejoice etc. From Georgia up to Lake Champlain From seas to Mississippi's shore; Ye sons of freedom loud proclaim, The Reign of Terror is no more. Rejoice-Columbia's sons, rejoice! To tyrants never bend the knee; But join with heart, and soul and voice For JEFFERSON and LIBERTY."Latest Government Technology News