Former Homeland Security Chief Slams Interoperability Progress
Feb 16, 2007, By Steve Towns, Editor
Former Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge Wednesday called for the creation of a nationwide public-safety communications network.
Ridge, U.S. homeland security director from 2001 to 2005, said radio spectrum currently earmarked for sale to commercial communications companies should be set aside for police, fire and emergency responders. He also sharply criticized the lack of progress on interoperable emergency communications since the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.
"To be five and half years after 9/11 and be no further toward a national, broadband, interoperable communication system in my judgment is inexcusable," Ridge said in an interview with Government Technology Magazine.
Ridge supports a proposal by Morgan O'Brien, co-founder of Nextel Communications, to create a nationwide broadband public safety network from a slice of spectrum in the 700 MHz band that is scheduled for auction in 2008. Instead of selling the spectrum to private companies, Ridge advocated placing the bandwidth in a public trust.
"You've got the spectrum. You've got the bandwidth. It's out there. Congress wants to sell it commercially, and once it's sold commercially, it's gone," he said. "Why would we not -- in a post 911 world -- want to create a nationwide, broadband network for public safety users across the country?"
Ridge said development of interoperable communications systems has been hampered by proprietary technologies and entrenched interests. But the real responsibility rests with political officials, he added.
"At the end of the day, it's still not so much the private sector. It's up to the political secretaries and the FCC to say, 'Enough is enough.'"
Ridge, who now serves as senior adviser to Deloitte's state government practice, visited Sacramento Feb. 14 to deliver a keynote speech to the California Public Sector CIO Academy, a two-day training seminar for government IT professionals.
KW
Industry Solutions for Government
Read real world deployments of technology in government from our sponsors.
View All Industry Solutions
Related Products and Services
Get Govtech's Daily Newsletter
-
Warning to Vendors
Vendors charging high maintenance fees are put on notice to cut their rates by Steve Emanuel, CIO of Montgomery County, Md.
-
Virtual Beverly Hills 1
Spanning earthquakes to water meters, Beverly Hills rolled out an interactive and interoperable Web-based GIS portal for emergency operations and public information.
-
Virtual Beverly Hills 2
Virtual Beverly Hills was recently challenged when a crowd of more than 20,000 ran through town.
More Video >
Comments
Lots of people talking about a nationwide public safety radio network. What do these people think they mean when they advocate such a system? What will be the coverage requirement? Are they talking seamless coverage that will allow users to roam with continuous coverage? Will rural areas have similar coverage and bandwidth as urban areas? If so, the price tag is going to be monumental and building it will take decades, all while technology keeps changing and improving. If not, the system will be a waste of money because public safety and homeland security isn't confined to urban areas. Before saying this is a good idea we really need to know the details of how it will be implemented.
Interesting Mr. Ridge that when you were Governor of Pennsylvania you had the opportunity to put 2500 Deputies on the strees to protect Pennsylvania and you chose to back the State Police and deny the Sheriffs their opportunity to protect the people, and he's blasting someone else about interoperability, how about no operability for the Sheriffs?
If you dedicate a specific bandwidth, haven't you also given every terrorist an easy target to knock out all emergency communications?
Seems that Mr. Ridge is talking out both sides of his mouth -- ask him about the state of Pa radio system and how "interop" it really is.
Mr. Ridge is right on target. Selling off all the bandwith to private industry is crazy. What will happen is private industry will lease it back to government costing taxpayers money for something they already own through government. Washington has it wrong again. Big surprise. Ridge should be President.
I totally agree. I had a chance to meet with Mr. Ridge when he was the head of DHS and interoperability was a key topic. As a local emergency mgr. I am very concerned about interoperability. The current head of DHS Mr. Chertoff seems to be only concerned about the federal level of homeland secruity, he gives little to no time to local programs. Don Scott Bernalillo County Emergency Manager Albuquerque New Mxico
Latest Government Technology News