Government Technology
Public CIO Magazine: Technology news to public sector C-level executives

Legally Speaking

Legally Speaking

Jul 9, 2007, By Matt Winstanley

Found in: Public Safety / Justice / Homeland Security

No one should be surprised, least of all government managers responsible for data, that legal discovery is getting more rigorous when it comes to electronically stored information.

The number of requests for production, or discovery, has been increasing for years. Some old-timers can remember when the Department of Justice launched the historic antitrust case against IBM on the last day of the Lyndon B. Johnson administration. IBM, like many other companies' regulatory-compliance responses, delivered trailer loads of paper files to the department.

Electronic records have garnered more attention as government relies more on electronic records and electronic communication (which is now designated as an electronic record). Also, attention has increased as the rules on these electronic communications expand. For example, rules on e-mails designated as public records specify that a record comprises more than just the e-mail's text. The format, editing history, forwarding history and other metadata are all considered part of that electronic record and must be accounted for.

Indeed, electronic records alone are not the only fair game for legal e-discovery. Everything a government department or agency creates is, for legal purposes, "discoverable." Photos, instant messages, voicemail messages, documents (all hard copy and electronic versions, no matter who edited them and when) and e-mail -- regardless of how trivial -- are considered "enterprise content" and must all be presentable in an e-discovery process.

There is no getting around an e-discovery process. It is in an agency's best interests to address e-discovery needs sooner rather than later. Case in point: As part of e-discovery laws, the judiciary is directed to ascertain whether an organization has adequately managed its electronic information. Organizations that can demonstrate good information management practices are granted leniency, or a "safe harbor"; those that do not are subject to direct access to their information systems.

Compliance is now law. And the consequences for not complying -- for not being prepared in an e-discovery situation -- can be devastating.


Understanding E-Discovery
The first step to understanding the e-discovery process is to define the terms.

E-discovery is the U.S. legal process through which attorneys obtain information in electronic form in response to litigation or regulatory action. The e-discovery process involves full disclosure of all electronic information relating to the matter at hand. That electronic information includes ordinary office documents, e-mails, Web sites, voicemail messages, employee cell-phone records and instant messages.

That also means every mobile device -- every notebook PC, BlackBerry, PDA, cell phone, thumb drive and flash memory card -- is considered a repository of discoverable data.

You may be asking: Why now? What has changed?

Good questions.

  • In September 2006, civil procedure rules regarding discovery were revised to explicitly cover electronic records. The rules were put forth by the Committee of Rules of Practice and Procedure of the U.S. Judicial Conference. These rules aren't just for companies. They apply to government agencies as well.
  • Federal IT and information managers now operate under guidelines in the Federal Enterprise Architecture Records Management Profile. These, plus other recent rules from the National Archives and Records Administration, rule out any investments in new IT systems until an agency can clearly specify its record management procedures.

In other words, it is no longer merely good information practice to create and store records so that they are retrievable. The ability to respond to an e-discovery court order requires more than a good records management system because e-discovery applies to all electronic content.


Meeting Demands
So how do government CIOs and IT staffs deal with it all? In three essential steps: assess, plan and implement. Within each step, you'll need to address the question of policies and products.

If You Liked This Article, You May Also Like...

Related Products and Services

Latest News in Public Safety / Justice / Homeland Security


Latest Government Technology News


Industry Solutions for Government

Read real world deployments of technology in government from our sponsors.

View All Industry Solutions

Marketplace


This section
brought to you by:
Ca - Transforming IT Management

IT Governance
Survey

Take this survey and get complimentary access to:

  • Gartner's: Magic Quadrant for IT Project and Portfolio Management, 2007
  • The Forrester Wave: Project Portfolio Management Tools, Q4 2007, Forrester, December 2007

The Power of IT Helps Oakland County, Michigan, Develop a High-Tech Future

  Yes! I would like more information about CA's solutions for Government.

IT Governance

CA Information Governance Solution Brief The CA Information Governance solution helps you solve an array of challenges with unique offerings including federated records management, email management, retention management and business process automation.

The Power of IT Helps Oakland County, Michigan, Develop a High-Tech Future CA helped Oakland County implement effective IT Governance and Service Management Solutions to support the evolution of their economy.

University Safeguards Wired & Wireless Access CA's Network ensures availability & performance of key systems with single, unified view.

CA Network & Voice Management Solution Brief Integrated, fault and performance management for end-to-end service assurance of multi-vendor, multi-technology converged networks.

IT Governance: Making the Difference in Cities, Counties and States Project and portfolio management helps government respond to old and new challenges. Featuring case studies from California Department of Agriculture, New York City, and Oakland County, Michigan.

Identity and Access Management

I Am Who I Say I Am: The Role of Identity and Access Management in Government. This whitepaper examines the role of Identity and Access Management in government using drivers such as the Real ID act and HSPD-12 as its guide.

Commonwealth of PA DPW Achieves Efficient Identity and Access Management with CA Identity Manager and eTrust® SiteMinder® The nearly 300 legacy applications at the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania -- Department of Public Welfare (DPW) were deployed as separate silos, each with its own user interface, access control list, security logic, business logic and IT support team

Project & Portfolio Management

Smart Enterprise Magazine Article: Bherwani Featuring Kamal Bherwani, CIO of New York City's Department of Health

Smart Enterprise Magazine Article: Cosgrove How Paul Cosgrave, New York City's CIO, helps keep the country's biggest city humming along.

Risk Compliance and Best Practices

The Changing Face of Network Management Automated NCCM tools reduce the downtime and degradation caused by configuration changes.

Business Service Management Links IT Services To Business Goals Adopting a process-centric approach to IT, applying ITIL® best practices and building a service-oriented team culture

IT Service Management Process Maps Select your route to ITIL© Best Practice

Deploying the CMDB for Change & Configuration Management The Configuration Management Database (CMDB) plays a critical role within the ITIL framework.