Government Technology
Government Technology: State & Local Government News Articles

Facebook's Response to Terms of Service Flap Offers a Governance Lesson

Bookmark and Share
Comment

May 1, 2009, By Paul W. Taylor

"Launch and learn," the watchwords of Web 2.0, sound a lot like "crash and burn."

Facebook, the social networking site that boasts 175 million users, threaded that needle in February -- not through technology, but governance. Facebook's unilateral change to its terms of service created uproar about who owns and controls user-generated content.

CEO Mark Zuckerberg blogged about the dustup: "History tells us that systems are most fairly governed when there is an open and transparent dialog between the people who make decisions and those who are affected by them." He then replaced the existing terms of service with Facebook principles and a statement of rights and responsibilities, the latter to be reviewed and voted on by users.

Facebook confronted issues that have long bedeviled governments: transparency and openness. Whose information is it? How long should it be retained? How and where should we discuss these issues? (In "Town Halls," says Facebook, a forum created by and for government.) What language do we use to talk about this stuff? (Plain and simple.)

If government can teach Facebook the complexity of these issues -- and it can -- the site showed agility and determination under pressure by dusting itself off after a big public mistake. The Facebook experience provides reminders about good governance:

  • Speed-to-message: Once Facebook realized the problem, it regrouped to figure out a plan B and launched it within a week -- perhaps still too long in a 24/7 environment where people can mutiny with a mouse click, but much more responsive than the 30 to 90 days public agencies often afford themselves for policy review.
  • A principled approach: There may not be specific policy guidance to anticipate every future development. When in doubt, refer to the principles.
  • The rules are for everybody: The new principles advocate one "set of principles, rights and responsibilities that should apply to all ... whether individual, advertiser, developer, organization or other entity." It's a high bar, but it provides at least an initial hedge against favoritism or special deals, which are the bane of effective governance.
  • Upfront about the non-negotiables: The service provider is explicitly not part of "everybody." Facebook reserves the right to stir the pot occasionally, stating it "is still in the business of introducing new and therefore potentially disruptive technologies," Zuckerberg wrote. "We need to continue to make independent decisions about products in order to push technology forward." Importantly those "will not be subject to the notice and comment or voting requirement," he wrote. On balance, it's a reasonable (and necessary) stance for a provider to take if its mandate is imagining the future, and then building it.

The current case gives an important example of when the two in Web 2.0 stands for second chance. What have we learned from this about-face? Being fast is good. Being right is better. Listening and developing policy iteratively may prove to be -- in the end -- the best. To Facebook's credit, it regrouped quickly with a surprising second chance -- one in which it remembers that conversation and community is based on two-way communication. When you're Web 2.0, you have to act Web 2.0.


Editor's Note: This column originally appeared as About-Face(book) in the May print edition of Government Technology magazine.

 

MJ

Latest Government Technology News


Industry Solutions for Government

Read real world deployments of technology in government from our sponsors.

View All Industry Solutions

Related Products and Services

Marketplace


Get Public CIO's Bi-Weekly Newsletter
This section
brought to you by:

CA RC Q1 2010 Resource Center

Take our Identity
Lifecycle Management (ILM) Survey

Can your organization keep pace with its growing demands while enforcing security controls?

Mainframe

White Paper: The Mainframe Opportunity IT Strategies For Achieving Breakthrough Value

Forrester conducted interviews with CIOs/CTOs of mainframe users in the US and Europe to better understand their strategies in the use of the mainframe.

Strategy Paper: CA's Mainframe 2.0 Strategy Roadmap

Fully capitalize on the potential value offered by the mainframe as the availability of mainframe professionals becomes increasingly constrained.

MF 2.0 Product Brochure

Mainframe 2.0 is CA’s new and far-reaching initiative that is changing the way the mainframe is managed forever.


Cybersecurity

IDC White Paper - Identity Lifecycle Management: Bringing Together Security, Identity and Compliance

Read this to learn about the technology and best practices needed to manage your identities throughout their lifecycle.

I Am Who I Say I Am

This paper discusses the drivers, responses and challenges associated with information security in Government.

Simplify and Secure: Managing User Identities Throughout their Lifecycles

Find solutions that simplify, automate and secure the activities for creating and modifying user identities and roles throughout the organization.

Virtualization / Cloud Computing

White Paper: Integrated Infrastructure and Performance Management for Virtualized Environments

Government agencies use virtualized environments to decrease costs, consolidate data centers and reduce environmental impacts.

CA Virtualization Management

CA Virtualization Management solutions provide integrated end-to-end management, automation and security which drive better outcomes.

Working Together to Maximize Business Value of Your IT Investments

VMware and CA have responded to your requirements by forging a solid partnership focused on your enterprise's needs.

Project and Portfolio Management

A Life Cycle Approach to Grants Management

Using project management at every stage of grant administration can maximize funds now and for the future.

A Platform for the New Transparency: Meeting the Challenge of ARRA Grants Management in State and Local Government

The sheer size of ARRA and new grant opportunities has had a tremendous impact on the workload of grants management staff. But the size of the program is only part of the story.

Success Stories: IT Governance: Making the Difference in Cities, Counties and States

Decision-makers need to align IT projects with organizational goals.  See how three agencies achieved this.

Government Jobs

Browse hundreds of public sector career opportunities in GovTech's new jobs section. Popular job searches: government IT, public safety, GIS, transportation, CIO, security, health