Government Technology
Government Technology: State & Local Government News Articles

Can Other States Learn from Michigan Agency Consolidations? (Opinion)

Bookmark and Share
Comment

Jan 26, 2010, By Paul W. Taylor

In 12 short months, chances are you will be deciding whether to rent a tuxedo and buy tickets for the inaugural ball. Protracted court challenges notwithstanding, the results of the 2010 gubernatorial elections should be known by then. The combination of term limits and retirements mean that at least 20 states will elect new governors, but two-thirds of all states will have contests for the role of chief executive.

As transitions typically go, there will be numerous empty seats around the Cabinet table when inauguration day rolls around. But there may be fewer chairs to fill. Permanently.

Take Michigan. The state was first in and hardest hit by the fiscal crisis, owing in no small measure to its reliance on the legacy automobile industry. Just as General Motors jettisoned Pontiac, Saturn and Saab to focus on its core brands (Chevrolet, Cadillac, Buick and GMC), so too the state is trimming its portfolio.

Gov. Jennifer Granholm asked Lt. Gov. John Cherry this year to propose a plan to reduce the number of state departments from 18 to eight. Cherry has reduced the number to seven core functions of government:

1. public safety;
2. education;
3. public systems (transportation, water, energy and information technology);
4. well-being (medical care, social services and public assistance);
5. sustainability (natural resources);
6. economic opportunity and prosperity (attracting investment, business regulation and consumer affairs); and
7. efficiency and effectiveness (transparency, administration and fiscal management).

It's easy to see elements of a CIO-led organization in a number of those core functions. As a practical matter, Granholm is placing IT back into the state's Department of Management and Budget. The change's announcement called the move a "merger" that brings the total agency count to 15, down from the constitutional cap of 20 agencies, the state's level just a few years ago.

One state employee enthused that the consolidation brings with it "all kinds of remarkable ICT [information and communication technology] infusion possibilities at the enterprise and shared service levels."

Ken Theis, the current state CIO, will oversee the consolidation of the two departments and will ultimately be named the new department's director.

Theis' elevation mirrors an expanded span of control granted to local government public CIOs to the roles of assistant city manager or county executive. It legitimizes the management prowess and strategic vision of those originally appointed to manage technology alone. His challenge will be to institutionalize the multiplying and forcing effect of technology on the way the state does business.

In a recent conversation about the structural changes under way in Michigan -- and on the horizon elsewhere if projections by the National Governors Association and a growing number of think tanks are accurate -- Theis told me, "I don't see us getting through this and looking anything near what we look like today."

That's true of government structures in general and the role of the public CIO. But the question is different this time. It's not about the merits of being a political appointee or career civil servant. It's about whether the role will still be recognizable as we have come to know it in the years since it emerged from finance and administration departments in the first place, or whether it will exist at all.

 

MJ

Comments

By Bill Bott on Jan 26, 2010

This "pillars of government" idea has been around for awhile with no one brave enough to pull the trigger on such a massive org change - I'm most interested in how it can potentially revolutionize data sharing between areas - most people would be shocked how little departments share with one another - with giant silos tipping over, hopefully some of the smaller ones will follow.

Respond to a comment.

Latest Government Technology News


Industry Solutions for Government

Read real world deployments of technology in government from our sponsors.

View All Industry Solutions

Related Products and Services

Marketplace


Get Public CIO's Bi-Weekly Newsletter
This section
brought to you by:

CA RC Q1 2010 Resource Center

Take our Identity
Lifecycle Management (ILM) Survey

Can your organization keep pace with its growing demands while enforcing security controls?

Mainframe

White Paper: The Mainframe Opportunity IT Strategies For Achieving Breakthrough Value

Forrester conducted interviews with CIOs/CTOs of mainframe users in the US and Europe to better understand their strategies in the use of the mainframe.

Strategy Paper: CA's Mainframe 2.0 Strategy Roadmap

Fully capitalize on the potential value offered by the mainframe as the availability of mainframe professionals becomes increasingly constrained.

MF 2.0 Product Brochure

Mainframe 2.0 is CA’s new and far-reaching initiative that is changing the way the mainframe is managed forever.


Cybersecurity

IDC White Paper - Identity Lifecycle Management: Bringing Together Security, Identity and Compliance

Read this to learn about the technology and best practices needed to manage your identities throughout their lifecycle.

I Am Who I Say I Am

This paper discusses the drivers, responses and challenges associated with information security in Government.

Simplify and Secure: Managing User Identities Throughout their Lifecycles

Find solutions that simplify, automate and secure the activities for creating and modifying user identities and roles throughout the organization.

Virtualization / Cloud Computing

White Paper: Integrated Infrastructure and Performance Management for Virtualized Environments

Government agencies use virtualized environments to decrease costs, consolidate data centers and reduce environmental impacts.

CA Virtualization Management

CA Virtualization Management solutions provide integrated end-to-end management, automation and security which drive better outcomes.

Working Together to Maximize Business Value of Your IT Investments

VMware and CA have responded to your requirements by forging a solid partnership focused on your enterprise's needs.

Project and Portfolio Management

A Life Cycle Approach to Grants Management

Using project management at every stage of grant administration can maximize funds now and for the future.

A Platform for the New Transparency: Meeting the Challenge of ARRA Grants Management in State and Local Government

The sheer size of ARRA and new grant opportunities has had a tremendous impact on the workload of grants management staff. But the size of the program is only part of the story.

Success Stories: IT Governance: Making the Difference in Cities, Counties and States

Decision-makers need to align IT projects with organizational goals.  See how three agencies achieved this.

Government Jobs

Browse hundreds of public sector career opportunities in GovTech's new jobs section. Popular job searches: government IT, public safety, GIS, transportation, CIO, security, health