May 13, 2005 By Blake Harris
Even the National Foreign Intelligence Board's conservative Global Trends 2015 report noted "The state will remain the single most important organizing unit of political, economic, and security affairs through 2015 but will confront fundamental tests of effective governance."
The fact that such a report even discussed the question highlights that the potential decline of the nation state has received serious attention by more than a few. And certainly when considered in the context of economic globalization, the establishment of regional free-trading blocs, a growing number of international regulatory treaties and the increasing influence of NGOs operating transnationally, there is little dispute that the challenges to governments at all levels have become increasingly complex.
Underpinning an array of shifting political and social dynamics lies a fundamental social transformation that futurists and sociologists have been investigating and describing for years -- a transformation that continues to produce new unanticipated twists and turns.
"As the rate of change becomes faster, governments -- federal, state or provincial and municipal -- seem to become more dysfunctional," notes W.R. Clement, a long time policy consultant to the Canadian government and author of Quantum Jump: A Survival Guide for the New Renaissance.
On one level, that view seems rather brutal. For years Government Technology has reported on IT innovations and applications which continue to improve the quality and efficiency of service delivery to citizens. Web pages, GIS applications, integrated justice solutions, improved customer access 24/7 and better data management are just some of the benefits that have improved government service delivery.
However, the dysfunction of which Clement speaks refers not to the obvious successes of solving old problems better, but rather meeting an entirely different set of circumstances that global transformation is now thrusting upon governments -- problems that appear as challenges requiring new solutions on top of all the legacy solutions for old traditional problems.
He doesn't delineate challenges as they exist for local governments per say. Yet it is here that the cracks become most obvious, especially if we think of local government as the activity that most directly shapes the health and prosperity of the communities in which we live. Traditionally local governments did much to attract and foster the industries that created employment and wealth for a municipality. They built the infrastructure of our towns and cities that has in large measure defined how we live our lives. They educated new generations so social progress continued to be made. And they maintained law and order, protecting citizens and thereby helping the honest to live decent and productive lives.
Today, however, the traditional role of local government is increasingly challenged by trends and forces over which they seemingly have little effective control. In some ways, local communities are like a ship on the high seas being battered and tossed by hurricane winds and waves ---- a tempest of change. Except the fierce winds have risen slowly, so their growing ferocity has scarcely been noticed. The result is that what once would have been viewed as a social calamity now passes for normal.
Drugs seemingly pour into the country virtually unchecked, making billions for international drug cartels. This fuels increasingly high crime rates, with millions now housed in prisons at public expense. And it spurs gang violence, dangerous streets, and cancerous sub-cultures of questionable social contributions. Local governments directly face the effects year after year.
Terrorism has become the primary vehicle for waging war against America. People plotting in secret on the other side of the globe how have placed tremendous new burdens upon local
You may use or reference this story with attribution and a link to