Santa Rosa Sues PG&E, Seeking Financial Damages from October Wildfires

While Cal Fire’s report on the deadly Tubbs fire is not out yet, the agency has determined that PG&E power equipment was responsible for causing 16 other major fires across Northern California in October.

by J.D. Morris and Kevin McCallum, The Press Democrat, Santa Rosa, Calif. / July 18, 2018

(TNS) — Santa Rosa, Calif., is suing PG&E over the damage caused by October’s devastating wildfires and their aftermath, joining a broader legal fight involving several other local governments seeking compensation from the utility for taxpayer costs incurred because of the disaster.

Santa Rosa filed the lawsuit July 11 in Sonoma County Superior Court and announced it Tuesday after the city attorney disclosed the filing in a report to the City Council. Sonoma, Lake, Mendocino and Napa counties are already suing the utility over the fires, which leveled entire neighborhoods in Santa Rosa, including much of Fountaingrove and Coffey Park. The fires destroyed 5,300 homes in Sonoma County and killed 24 people.

A city spokeswoman said the suit will be consolidated with others filed by local governments.

Vice Mayor Chris Rogers said the city has been discussing the issue for months and gave its legal staff the authority to move forward if Cal Fire finds PG&E’s equipment to be responsible for the fires.

While Cal Fire’s report on the deadly Tubbs fire is not out yet, the agency has determined that PG&E power equipment was responsible for causing 16 other major fires across Northern California in October, including blazes that burned across Sonoma, Lake, Napa and Mendocino counties. Those findings gave city officials confidence to move forward with the suit, believing PG&E “will also be found to have contributed significantly to the cause of the Tubbs fire,” city officials said in a Tuesday statement.

“We’re trying to make sure we pursue every avenue for making our community whole,” Rogers said in an interview.

PG&E spokeswoman Deanna Contreras said the utility is still reviewing Santa Rosa’s lawsuit.

“Nothing is more important to us than the safety and well-being of our customers and communities we serve. Our thoughts are with everyone impacted by these devastating wildfires,” she said. “We’re focused on doing everything we can to help these communities rebuild and recover.”

Separately, the utility is being sued by hundreds of North Bay residents who lost their homes in the fires.

Santa Rosa officials said in their statement Tuesday that the city’s lawsuit seeks recovery of unspecified financial damages and allows the city to join others hoping to make PG&E “implement new safety measures to prevent future disasters.”

“Our city suffered tremendous social and economic loss and faces millions of dollars of expense for emergency response and recovery efforts, including the ongoing work of rebuilding damaged infrastructure,” the statement said. “We must take action to seek fair compensation and reimbursement from the responsible parties, so that our community can move forward toward full recovery and secure the future safety of our citizens.”

The 74-page lawsuit accuses PG&E of “well-documented systemic failures, including lack of adequate safety regulations, inspection, maintenance, and risk management practices” that caused or contributed to the October fires, the most destructive in state history.

While the various fires that ignited around Northern California had different origin points, the suit says all of them “share the same underlying causes,” having arisen from the utility’s inattention to “mandated safety practices and foreseeable hazardous risks associated with its infrastructure.”

The suit also accuses PG&E of a “willful and conscious disregard of public safety.” It seeks an award of financial damages on several fronts, including for replacement of destroyed property, economic losses, the operation of evacuation centers, staff overtime, additional law enforcement costs and damage to public infrastructure.


©2018 The Press Democrat (Santa Rosa, Calif.)

Visit The Press Democrat (Santa Rosa, Calif.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.