Clickability tracking pixel

Patient Surge Coming, Then Another? Officials Just Don’t Know

The first surge might not overwhelm hospital beds, emergency rooms and intensive care units. But with the experience of Italian hospitals as a telling recent precedent, some are bracing for a second surge.

by Frederick Melo, Pioneer Press, St. Paul, Minn. / March 18, 2020

(TNS) — Some doctors and public health experts call it the surge. Many are referring to it as the curve.

But perhaps it’s best to think of it as the patient swarm — the moment when those who have been infected for days with a virus 10 times deadlier than the flu finally begin exhibiting serious symptoms and rush to medical facilities for emergency care all at once.

The first surge might not overwhelm hospital beds, emergency rooms and intensive care units.

But with the experience of Italian hospitals as a telling recent precedent, some are bracing for a second surge, when all the people unknowingly infected by those in the first patient wave also become ill, overloading hospital networks already at capacity.

And some of those infected will be the doctors and nurses on the front lines — caregivers who, in many areas, are already in short supply.


When is surge one, and are we doing enough to “flatten the curve” and avoid, or at least lessen the impact of, surge two?

“We don’t know at this point,” said Dr. Alison Peterson, a vice president of medical affairs at United Hospital in St. Paul. “We just don’t know.”

But Allina Health — United’s parent company — isn’t taking chances.

Since late February, Peterson has assumed the position of operations chief within the health network’s new incident command center in Minneapolis, where executive decisions are being made to free up hospital beds and prepare for the worst.

Allina Health, M Health Fairview and HealthPartners have announced that all elective surgeries will be postponed to make room for the surge, or surges, whenever they come. More healthcare providers are expected to do the same.

“We are doing everything we can to flatten the curve so we do not overwhelm our health resources within our communities,” Peterson said.

Meanwhile on Tuesday Allina Health announced it is no longer doing outpatient testing for COVID-19 at clinics, urgent cares, and emergency departments. The intent is to conserve resources for the most critically ill patients and ensure the safety of their staff, according to a statement released by Allina, Those patients needing hospitalization may still be tested.


Despite many unknowns, what’s clear is that there’s no longer anything foreign about what some leaders in government once labeled a “foreign virus,” and there’s no vaccine for it.

People no longer have to have traveled outside the country, or have spent time with someone who has, to be at serious risk of coronavirus infection. The fast-spreading virus could live on a doorknob, or jump from person to person.

In public health parlance, that’s called “community transmission,” and it’s here now in multiple Minnesota counties.

Of the 4,226 nationwide cases of coronavirus known to the Centers for Disease Control, only 229 cases were confirmed travel-related as of Monday. Another 245 cases involved close contact with someone who had traveled.

And the other 3,752 cases? Those are still under investigation, according to the CDC. In other words: who knows?

“From the highest density of population, it’s beginning to migrate outward,” Peterson said. “The map is a telling spread. The MDH (Minnesota Department of Health) has confirmed there is community spread without evidence of a travel contact.”


While the federal government initially focused on containing the virus — keeping it outside the U.S. — by banning European visitors, governors, medical directors and public health advocates have begged for more focus on mitigating it, or slowing and staggering the spread enough that hospitals can handle each wave.

On Friday, President Trump agreed it was time to limit contact between groups of 10 people or more, and individual cities and states have begun ordering social gathering spaces to close and issued limited “stay-home” orders.

Curtailing St. Patrick’s Day celebrations, Gov. Tim Walz on Monday ordered all bars, restaurants, museums, fitness clubs, theaters and country clubs closed by 5 p.m. Tuesday.


So when is this big patient surge coming?

“We really don’t know when this will peak,” said Dr. Mai Pho, an infectious disease specialist based in Chicago. “It depends on how well we will be able to ramp up our ability to test people, and how much we can maintain social distancing.”

She added: “The more we can, the further off we can push the peak and the better chance we have to protect our most vulnerable, and reduce the stress on the healthcare system.”

In other words, added Pho, “stay home, cancel everything and wash your hands.”


Most people infected with coronavirus will survive it, suffering only flu-like symptoms, and many — especially children — will become “stealth carriers” with no visible symptoms at all.

But hospitals and healthcare systems that already operate near capacity can be quickly overwhelmed, and coronavirus has proven deadliest among those with the most complicated medical needs, such as seniors and patients who have pre-existing conditions such as diabetes or hypertension. Cardiac and respiratory patients are especially vulnerable.

Then there’s the question of preparedness. In light of supply shortages, U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar and U.S. Sen. Tina Smith, both D-Minn., wrote a letter to Vice President Pence on Tuesday calling for the White House to boost public access to Food and Drug Administration-regulated medical products and hygiene products, including hand soap.

“We have heard widespread reports — including from hospitals, health systems, and long-term care facilities in our state — that health care providers across the country are facing shortages of medical supplies like ventilators, masks, hand sanitizer and soap,” Klobuchar and Smith wrote.

Even virus tests are in short supply nationally, and being targeted in Minnesota to high-risk populations such as healthcare workers and residents of care facilities.

My wife (potentially our entire family) was exposed to a confirmed case of #coronavirus last Wednesday. A doctor has denied us tests because we're under 60. Where are the tests in #Minnesota? @GovTimWalz @MayorCarter @Jacob_Frey @russellstark23 @VP @FrederickMelo

— Grant (@Melodic_Data) March 17, 2020


What does it look like when a hospital is overwhelmed? Reports from Italy describe intensive care units where medical care is being rationed to focus on infected patients who have a better chance of survival.

Are we the next Italy?

“We’re sort of following that Italy pattern, but we don’t know,” said Ritesh Patel, CEO of Open Cities Community Health Center in St. Paul, which serves particularly vulnerable low-income populations. “We don’t know if our rate is going to be double Italy, or avoid it. The strain could mutate, or be more virulent than the one in Italy.”

What is known is that coronavirus is measurably more contagious and spreads faster than the common flu. While studies vary, its mortality rate, or death rate, is roughly 10 times greater. And unlike the flu, there’s no vaccine — the best doctors can do is manage symptoms.

It’s unclear when a surge may occur, but “I expect over the next few days there to be an exponential increase,” said Dr. Cynthia Woods, medical director with Open Cities. “Now we have community transition, which means that somebody went to the grocery store and had no travel history, had not been around anyone who tested positive, and at some point contracted the virus. It spreads faster.”


©2020 the Pioneer Press (St. Paul, Minn.)

Visit the Pioneer Press (St. Paul, Minn.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

E.REPUBLIC Platforms & Programs