December 11, 2012 By Noelle Knell
According to the E-Government Satisfaction Index, conducted by consumer analytics firm ForeSee, three out of four citizens prefer to deal with their government online, as opposed to in person. Several federal agencies actually outrank well known private-sector e-retailers like Amazon on consumer satisfaction with online transactions. “By any measure, many government agencies are now outpacing their private-sector rivals, which is a development that very few thought likely,” the report concluded.
Those are the kinds of results Hawaii CIO Sanjeev “Sonny” Bhagowalia hopes to bring to the state by implementing his “online versus in line” vision for service delivery. Named the state’s first CIO in summer 2011, he brings a resumé that includes 14 years at Boeing, as well as key roles in the federal government, most recently leading e-government programs for the General Services Administration.
For a small state, Hawaii has some significant challenges ahead. Leaders confess that the fragmented physical nature of the islands has led to a disjointed system of technology infrastructure. The state workforce has gotten by delivering services using disparate legacy systems past their prime with business processes to match. With maintenance costs for these aging systems growing every year, most agree that Hawaii is in desperate need of a technology overhaul. The good news is that the state seems well positioned to deliver.
Sonny Bhagowalia, CIO, Hawaii
Photo by Jessica Mulholland
An avid proponent of the principles of open government, Bhagowalia last year released a 1,432-page document aimed to make up for 30 years of underfunding for technology. The Technology/Information Resource Management Transformation Plan sets an ambitious agenda stretching over the next 12 years, focusing on the transformation of Hawaii’s business processes, information resource management and IT.
The plan was opened up for public comment in order to gather some feedback on the strategy going forward.
“I feel like when you put the ideas out there, you benefit from clearly articulating a vision, but also incorporating changes and ideas from citizens, academia, industry and other government agencies,” Bhagowalia said.
While officials expected more comments than they actually received, Bhagowalia said it was indicative of island culture, where people tend to be more comfortable conveying their ideas behind the scenes. While some reviewers expressed a preference for a certain type of technology architecture over another, the state chose to keep the plan vendor neutral. Most people who commented, publicly and privately, relished the chance to weigh in on the plan and validated that its contents represented a solid foundation for the state.
As its name would imply, Hawaii’s Technology/Information Resource Management Transformation Plan takes on more than just technology. In order to effectively transform, hundreds of business processes across 18 state agencies will be modernized, using off-the-shelf technology whenever possible to keep costs under control.
But the technology is a means to enable more efficient business processes rather than the end game — an important distinction, according to Bhagowalia. “My job is to help the purveyors and the consumers of information get it from the providers of the information, and technology is a vessel to make that happen.”
Lacking a statewide Chief Information Office until Bhagowalia’s appointment, technology services have until now been fragmented and spread inefficiently throughout the state. The transformation plan pushes shared IT services and infrastructure. Implementation is envisioned akin to the initiatives in states such as Michigan and Utah, where technology functions operate like a utility, reducing duplication and complexity while enhancing reliability and service levels.
In line with Gov. Neil Abercrombie’s vision for open government, the transformation plan outlines several strategies to make the state as transparent as possible. The state’s recent launch of an open data portal, as well its participation in opendata.gov, the federal government’s multi-jurisdictional data site, provide evidence of this commitment.
An open data initiative aims to also encourage citizen engagement in problem-solving.
Today the state provides 150 different citizen services, but less than 5 percent of them are online. Bhagowalia would like to see all citizen-facing services online. A new state website, my.hawaii.gov, will allow Hawaiians to completely customize how they interact online with the state, based on the services they need. Mobile devices also factor heavily into Hawaii’s strategy, as the plan lays out the intent to have all services and information available securely, from any device.
While the plan stretches over 12 years in total, a phased yet flexible approach is recommended that offers opportunities for successes at regular intervals. Transparent progress tracking throughout the implementation process will measure customer satisfaction and allow for midstream course corrections.
Bhagowalia emphasized that the most significant and transformational change is impacting the organizational culture of the state’s 41,000-strong workforce. A change of this magnitude requires constant internal communication, and a commitment to empowering the workforce to assume ownership of its business areas and help advance a customer-focused vision of positive change.
Feedback on the plan while still in its draft stage underlined the need for a cultural change to implement the transformation successfully.
“The stumbling block to transformation in Hawaii is culture, not just in government but in the community in general. I'm glad to see that the IT/IRM Strategic Plan recognizes that it is proposing a cultural shift,” one reviewer noted.
Modernizing the business operations and technology operations of a state is bound to be a costly proposition. Bhagowalia secured a $25 million budget allocation in 2011, a supplemental budget year, which went toward plan development. Support from Abercrombie as well as the state Legislature is critical to the plan’s success, and Bhagowalia is optimistic that it will continue through the next phase: execution.
He explained that IT has been grossly underfunded in Hawaii for the past three decades, and transformation will require an increased share of the state’s $11 billion budget. Historically 1.4 percent of the budget has been devoted to IT. While he said an industry best practice is a funding level of 3 to 5 percent, implementation of needed changes for Hawaii will require an increase to about 2.4 percent, sustained over the duration of the implementation period.
“Thirty years of under funding can be fixed in 10 years of at least funding at an appropriate level,” he said. Despite tough budget times across the board in state government, he remains optimistic that it can be achieved, admitting that failure to fund at that 2.4 percent level will impact implementation.
“I believe the plan will survive and endure,” Bhagowalia concluded. “I think the people of Hawaii want this.”
Main photo of Poelua Bay in Maui, Hawaii, by Jessica Mulholland
You may use or reference this story with attribution and a link to